For individuals or business owners who have been affected by the Coronavirus (COVID-19) — find out how we may be able to help. Learn More

Is Closing a Credit Card a Good Idea?

closing a credit card

If you’re doing your best to stay out of debt, closing credit cards may seem like a smart option to help rid you of the temptation of charging. However, closing your credit card can actually have a negative impact on your credit score. Consider the effects on your overall financial situation before cutting the cord on your card.

How Closing a Credit Card affects your Credit Utilization

Your credit utilization rate is the ratio of your credit card debt to the total limit on all of your credit cards. For example, if you have $300 debt and your total credit card limit is $1,000, then your credit utilization is 30%. Closing a credit card can impact your credit utilization because you will be decreasing your amount of available credit. Keeping your credit utilization below 30% is generally considered best practice. By reducing your available credit, you could push your utilization over that rate, even if you haven’t increased your use.

Your credit utilization rate is responsible for about 30% of your FICO credit score, so any drastic changes may cause a sudden drop in your credit score. A low credit utilization shows lenders that although you are using credit, you are not dependent on it. This is therefore a testament to your creditworthiness.

How Closing a Credit Card affects the Length of your Credit History

It is beneficial to show a longstanding and positive credit history because it can help boost your credit score. Closing a credit card may result in a lower average age of accounts. This will be especially prominent if you are looking to close one of your older credit cards. The average age of accounts does play a role in determining your credit score. It is important for lenders to know how long you have been handling credit. A long, positive history shows lenders that you have sound financial habits that you’ve sustained over time.

Credit history makes up 15% of your FICO credit score. Therefore, the older the age of your account, the better it is for your credit score, because it considers the average age of all of your accounts. If you choose to close an older credit card, the average age of all accounts will be lowered. Therefore, your credit history may be negatively impacted.

Steps to Take Instead of Closing a Credit Card

Because closing a credit card can negatively impact your credit score, consider other options before making the decision. Closing the card may seem like a good idea if you’ve paid the balance and don’t want to be tempted to use it anymore. Consider stashing it away instead. Out of sight, out of mind, right? However, you may want to make a small transaction on it every once in a while to avoid the creditor closing it due to inactivity. Just be sure to pay the purchase off right away.

Not wanting to pay an annual fee is another common reason for closing a credit card. Consider downgrading to a lower-level card with the same creditor instead. However, be aware that doing so may decrease your credit limit. This will also impact your utilization – though not as much as closing the card all together.

Final Thoughts 

Closing your credit card could seem like a wise financial move for a number of reasons. However, many borrowers don’t realize that doing so can have a negative impact on your credit score. It’s important to note, also, that depending on other factors – such as how many other cards you have, how much debt you owe, etc. – your credit score will be affected to varying degrees. By understanding the effects of closing a credit card, you can make an informed decision about what is best for you and your financial situation.


If you have questions about managing your credit, contact the credit card debt professionals at Tayne Law Group.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Call Us Now to Get Started

(866) 890-7337

What People Have to Say

I just wanted to thank your entire staff at The Law Offices of Leslie H. Tayne, for helping me get out of debt. If it wasn’t for your firm, I would have never been able to resolve my $13k worth of debt in less than 3 years. Your staff did a great job, I was finally able to buy myself a brand new car without using a cosigner. I can’t tell you again how happy I am. I would recommend your services to anyone.

L.C. Client 2007-2009

I sleep like a baby at night now because of the work that you and your office have done. Rest assured that I will refer anyone I know to your office with conditions that are similarly circumstanced.

R.S. Client 2012-2014

You have been very helpful at first directing me in the right direction when I had no clue how to go about handling everything, I really appreciated all your advice and help and hope we can work something out. Thanks again for all your help and kind words, and patience.

D.M. Client 2009-2012

Call Now for a Free Consult
(866) 890-7337